City Hall Evaluations Shed Little Light – New Haven Independent

By Paul Bass

New Haven City Hall — where all the bosses are above average. In every way. At least according to the other bosses who rate them.

That’s the upshot of the latest round of annual performance evaluations of top city officials.

The evaluations conclude that all 15 officials in question rate as “satisfactory.” “Satisfactory” is defined here as “always achieves standards.” The definition continues: “Far exceeds expectations. Outstanding producer and extremely accurate worker. Achieves peak performance. Completely understands the relationship and duties of related jobs. Totally dependable in performing work, including non-routine assignments. Consistently responsive to work requests.”

The supervisors filling out the 15 reports checked that “satisfactory” box for not only the overall evaluations, but for all 11 categories contained in each report, ranging from “ethics in government” and “commitment to diversity” to “customer service.”

In not a single instance did a supervisor cite a shortcoming in space for written comments. Most of the evaluations contained no written performance details, period, with the exception of those prepared by Development Administrator Matthew Nemerson. (You can click on the evaluations at the bottom of the stories.)

“Real Superstars”

The Independent originally requested the 2014 evaluations on Feb. 15. OnlyNemerson and Mayor Harp had at the point completed their reviews of departments directly under their aegis, and Harp’s were notimmediately available for release. The rest of the reportswere made available over the past week. (Some remain AWOL, including those connected to human services.)The supervisors had to complete the annual evaluations of executive managers under Title III, Chapter 2 1/2 of the city code of ordinances. But that doesn’t mean they have to make them detailed evaluations.

Chief Administrative Officer Mike Carter, who oversees public safety, engineering and public works department heads, said he meets with them every week or two and reviews progress, problems and goals in depth. Mayor Harp said she does the same.

“In D.C., you write a whole textbook” in annual reviews, Carter said, referring to his previous government job. Washington, D.C. evaluations also included a rating system of 1-5. He learned upon coming here that because of the practice of evaluations becoming public, he should reserve detailed discussion of managers’ performance for in-person discussions. He said that supervision is taking place in a “continuous feedback model” with discussions with his managers about “how to improve.”

“The evaluation,” he said, “never stops. What’s important is to have constant dialogue. We have some great people here. They don’t all walk on water.” Click here and here to read about two working groups with which Carter has met regularly, to improve snow removal and modernize the fire department.

The city’s top managers are all doing well, according to Mayor Harp. She did fire one appointee early in her term—prison reentry coordinator Sundiata Keitazulu—after he was refused entry to prisons to work with prisoners because of outstanding warrants against him. And her administration placed another, Nichole Jefferson, on leave pending the results of an internal financial investigation.

Otherwise, Harp said Wednesday, sheis pleased with all her department heads’ performance.“I think I have a really good team,” Harp said. “Sometimes there are things that may happen in terms of communication that might be issue. But in terms of doing their job, I think they’re doing a good job.

“I have real superstars. They have done things of national significance. I think the work that [Youth Director] Jason is doing on Youth Stat has been recognized nationally. I really think that once the whole model is fine-tuned it is something that can be transferable to more places.”

Ongoing Good-Government Debate

On evaluations, the Harp administration is following a path forged by thepreviousDeStefano administration, which began sanitizing its evaluations in reaction to a 2004 state Freedom of Information Commission (FOIC) ruling requiring the city to make the evaluations open to public inspection.The DeStefano administration had fought a request to the FOIC to make performance evaluations public. After losing the case, the administration revised evaluations to include less information. Department heads have since been graded as “satisfactory” or “unsatisfactory,” period, and must simply initial that they have discussed their performance across the 11 categories. Any other comments are “optional,” and largely eschewed. Based on who’s doing the evaluations, some of the documents offer detailed, specific insight into how public servants are serving the public and how they can do better, in their bosses’ eyes; while others leave out any specific information or reflection of what the bosses are really thinking.

(“Unsatisfactory” is defined as “below minimum standards.” That means the manager “meets some job standard, or only the minimum standards necessary to complete assignments. Often requires supervision. Does not regularly perform full scope of job responsibilities. Marginally responsive to work requirements.”)

The Harp administration uses the form that the DeStefano administration created.

Some of the DeStefano administration evaluations eventually began including constructive feedback into the evaluations, with written comments offering detailed, specific insight into how public servants are serving the public and how they can do better, in their bosses’ eyes. (Click here, here and here for examples of different years’ evaluations.)

Informally that debate—over whether to make true evaluations public—has continued. It centers on how best to make government managers accountable in the interest of better serving the public. The arguments advanced can be boiled down as follows:

In favor of the current sanitized system: Effective supervisory feedback takes place in private, so as not to embarrass people among colleagues. That produces the best results for the public. The whittled-down, content-free forms follow the letter of the law and the FOIC ruling. New Haven voters elect a mayor every two years; that gives them the democratic ability to throw out the mayor’s top aides (who aren’t civil-service protected) if they believe those aides are doing a bad job.

In favor of writing and releasing true evaluations: “Transparency” or “sunshine”—in the form of public review of how top city officials rate the performance of their department heads, and what they are or are not doing to tackle problems—pushes government to confront problems rather than ignore them. Democracy doesn’t work best as simply an exercise of a single biennial, all-or-nothing vote on a single elected official. And in any case, the city should abide by the spirit, not just the letter, of freedom-of-information rulings.

Goals & Strokes
Mike Carter’s evaluations do mention specific goals he has set for his managers in 2015. Fire Chief Allyn Wright’s goals, for instance, include seating and graduating a second class of firefighters by June 30; selecting a third class; promoting lieutenants and captains; assessing firehouse repairs; updating IT systems up to state standards. City Engineer Giovanni Zinn’s goals include implementing the Complete Streets 2.0 traffic-calming program and developing green infrastructure and energy-efficiency initiatives. Parks chief Rebecca Bombero was directed to expand the concert in the parks series, introduce a film series, grow the parks’ friends groups, and expand turf life and playing fields.

The one supervisor to go beyond checking off boxes about their employees’ performance has been Nemerson, who hand-scribbled comments in the margins. Most of the comments were glowing, though some did contain constructive suggestions.

City Plan Executive Director Karyn Gilvarg? “One of the best,” Nemerson wrote. “Handles talented people who are under pressure all the time very well!” “Handles complicated things with grace and charm and humor.” She also has a commitment to diversity, he wrote, though she could use some “Spanish speakers on staff.”’

Livable City Initiative Executive Director Serena Neal-Sanjurjo? “An inspiring leader who I am delighted to have on the team,” Nemerson wrote.

Transit chief Douglas Hausladen has demonstrated a “remarkable learning curve,” in Nemerson’s words. “A true team player and advocate.” “Strives to be state of the art in everything you do! … Selling your vision.” “Careful to communicate well with pols + constituents.” Elaborating on the “satisfactory” score for “Work environment,” Nemerson wrote that Hausladen is “[d]oing this well now—had to ‘sell’ yourself to staff, but did it thru hard work.” As for “customer service,” Nemerson wrote, “A huge part of the job skill is knowing how to say no.”

Following are links to evaluations released to the Independent:

Parks chief Rebecca Bombero
911 call center chief Michael Briscoe
Library chief Martha Brogan
Budget chief Joe Clerkin
Police Chief Dean Esserman
City Plan chief Karyn Gilvarg
Transit chief Doug Hausladen
Controller Daryl Jones
Livable City Initiative (LCI) chief Serena Neal-Sanjurjo
Development chief Matthew Nemerson
Human resources chief Martha Okafor
Public works chief Jeff Pescosolido
Chief of Staff Tomas Reyes
Fire Chief Allyn Wright
City Engineer Giovanni Zinn

Tags: ,

122 Replies to “City Hall Evaluations Shed Little Light – New Haven Independent”

  1. This blog is really interesting, but why it is on 14th place in google’s search results.
    It deserves to be in top 5. Many bloggers think that seo is dead in 2016, but
    it’s not true. There is sneaky method to reach google’s top
    5 that not many people know. Just search for: pandatsor’s tools

  2. I simply want to mention I’m new to blogs and absolutely liked you’re blog site. Probably I’m want to bookmark your blog post . You amazingly come with perfect well written articles. Regards for sharing your webpage.

  3. My spouse and I stumbled over here by a different web address and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so i am just following you. Look forward to checking out your web page again.

  4. There are some interesting times in this write-up yet I don?t know if I see all of them facility to heart. There is some credibility however I will certainly hold opinion until I check into it additionally. Good post, many thanks as well as we want extra! Included in FeedBurner also

  5. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Many thanks, However I am going through troubles with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I can’t subscribe to it. Is there anyone else getting identical RSS issues? Anyone that knows the answer can you kindly respond? Thanks!!

  6. Saving our environment is very important and a priority for all of us. The surroundings is something that everyone has a component to play in preserving. Environment is essentially the most very important aspect of the human race and we now have an obligation to protect it. So, to save lots of nature, we must defend it and to protect the environment we should study about the importance and fragility of our environment.

  7. Hello.These posts was extremely interesting, particularly because I was looking for thoughts on this very topic last Thursday. I hope that you will read ours now available here

  8. This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and look forward to seeking more of your excellent post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks!

  9. Howdy! This post could not be written any better! Looking through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He always kept preaching about this. I will forward this post to him. Fairly certain he will have a great read. Thank you for sharing!

  10. Hello there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog. Is it very hard to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any points or suggestions? Appreciate it

  11. My brother recommended I might like this web site. He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

  12. I am now not positive where you are getting your information, but great topic. I needs to spend some time studying much more or understanding more. Thank you for magnificent information I was in search of this info for my mission.|

  13. Thanks for your concepts. One thing we’ve noticed is banks along with financial institutions are aware of the spending practices of consumers while also understand that most of the people max outside their cards around the trips. They correctly take advantage of this real fact and then start flooding a person’s inbox plus snail-mail box by using hundreds of no interest APR credit cards offers shortly when the holiday season closes. Knowing that when you are like 98% in the American general public, you’ll get at the one opportunity to consolidate financial debt and switch balances towards 0 rate credit cards. poonmpp – new cluster headache drug

  14. Thanks for your ideas. One thing I have noticed is that banks and financial institutions know the spending habits of consumers and understand that most people max out their credit cards around the holidays. They wisely take advantage of this fact and start flooding your inbox and snail-mail box with hundreds of 0 APR credit card offers soon after the holiday season ends. Knowing that if you are like 98% of the American public, you’ll jump at the chance to consolidate credit card debt and transfer balances to 0 APR credit cards. aaaaaaa – buy stomach pain meds

  15. Thanks for your advice on this blog. One particular thing I would choose to say is the fact purchasing gadgets items over the Internet is certainly not new. In truth, in the past few years alone, the marketplace for online gadgets has grown drastically. Today, you could find practically virtually any electronic tool and product on the Internet, including cameras in addition to camcorders to computer pieces and games consoles. – medication to stop hair loss

  16. Today, taking into consideration the fast chosen lifestyle that everyone is having, credit cards get this amazing demand throughout the market. Persons out of every arena are using credit card and people who not using the credit card have prepared to apply for just one. Thanks for spreading your ideas in credit cards. anti hypertension drugs

  17. I simply wanted to write a small word to be able to thank you for these stunning tips you are showing on this website. My time-consuming internet search has now been rewarded with reputable strategies to write about with my pals. I would state that that we website visitors are unquestionably lucky to live in a useful website with very many special professionals with very beneficial techniques. I feel very lucky to have used your entire website and look forward to some more fun times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything. drugs for bronchitis and pneumonia

  18. I realized more a new challenge on this fat loss issue. A single issue is that good nutrition is very vital any time dieting. A massive reduction in junk food, sugary food items, fried foods, sugary foods, beef, and white-colored flour products could be necessary. Having wastes parasitic organisms, and toxic compounds may prevent targets for fat loss. While specific drugs in the short term solve the situation, the awful side effects usually are not worth it, and so they never offer you more than a momentary solution. This is a known undeniable fact that 95% of celebrity diets fail. Thank you for sharing your opinions on this website. osteoporosis drugs

  19. I really wanted to write down a small word to be able to thank you for those wonderful tricks you are writing on this website. My time intensive internet search has now been rewarded with wonderful tips to write about with my two friends. I would tell you that we website visitors are very much lucky to live in a wonderful website with very many wonderful professionals with very helpful tricks. I feel very much privileged to have used your entire website page and look forward to tons of more thrilling times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything. what antibiotics treat bronchitis

  20. I realized more something totally new on this fat loss issue. 1 issue is that good nutrition is very vital whenever dieting. An enormous reduction in junk food, sugary food items, fried foods, sugary foods, beef, and whitened flour products could be necessary. Keeping wastes parasitic organisms, and toxic compounds may prevent targets for fat loss. While specific drugs in the short term solve the situation, the awful side effects usually are not worth it, and so they never offer you more than a momentary solution. This is a known undeniable fact that 95% of dietary fads fail. Thank you for sharing your opinions on this website. osteoporosis threatment

  21. I simply wanted to type a simple remark to be able to thank you for these stunning techniques you are showing on this site. My time-consuming internet research has now been recognized with reliable points to talk about with my neighbours. I would say that we website visitors are unquestionably lucky to live in a superb site with very many special professionals with valuable techniques. I feel truly lucky to have seen your entire webpages and look forward to some more fun times reading here. Thanks a lot once more for everything. drugs for bronchitis treatment

  22. แทงลูกฟุตบอล ออนไลน์ SBOAAAAA ใหม่เอี่ยมเวิกอุปถัมภ์บริการทิ่มลูกบอลออนไลน์ต่อจากนั้นวันนี้ รับเดิมพันออนไลน์กีฬาดีเยี่ยมกว่า 30 สายทั่วโลก พร้อมด้วยบริการบริเวณนาเนกขนานเสร็จมอบให้บริการ 24hr รองงานทำเพลงทุกรูปร่างไม่ว่าจักยังไม่ตายวิธีเลือก Mobile ก็ได้บรรเลง ทั้งนี้อีกต่างหากประกอบด้วยราคาลูกฟุตบอล Step มูลค่าท่วมท้นกระทั่งใคร โหยมันพิจารณาถึงกระผม กูพกเกมส์มาริยกให้คัดเลือกเล่นกว่า 500
    โปรแกรมประสานสัปดาห์ อัพเดทล่าสุด เป็นใหม่ทั้ง กะเกณฑ์ทั้งเป็นเว็บเสียบฟุตบอลบริเวณประเสริฐเต็มที่ภายในประเทศไทยเลย
    ทั้งนี้ยังทำได้เลือกสรรโจ้ฟุตบอลจัดหามาทั้งหมดลีก ทั่วแฝด ทั่วโลก พร้อมเสริฟลงมาส่งมอบคนเสียบลูกฟุตบอลออนไลน์ระบิลพร้อม ไม่ว่าจักคืองานเสียบลูกฟุตบอลออนไลน์ ,
    กะซวกบาส , เบสบอล , เทนนิส , อเมริกันบอล , กีฬาเสมือนนัก ,
    การเล่นสนุก , ออสเตรเลียน รูลส์ฟุตบอล
    , แบดมินตัน , บี้ดี้ , บอลชายฝั่ง , มวยฝรั่ง , มวยไทย , คริกเกต ,
    จักรยาน ,เกมส์โยนเป้า , อีสปอร์ต , ฮอกกี้ , ฟุตซอล , เอ็งลิบอล
    , กอล์ฟ , แฮนด์บอล ,
    ฮอกกี้น้ำแข็ง , กราบลาคเฝ้ารอส ,
    มอเตอร์สปอร์ต , รักบี้ , สควอช , เทโบยบินเอียงนิส , วอลเลย์ลูกฟุตบอล , โปโลน้ำดิบ โอลิมปิก ,
    กีฬาฤดูหนาวเหน็บ เป็นต้น อีกพรั่งพร้อม ทั้งหมดแบบมอบหยุดลูกฟุตบอลประณีตยิ่ง คุ้มด้วยกันสตางค์พนันระบิเป็นมั่นเป็นเหมาะ
    เอสบีโอเบท เว็บเสียบบอลออนไลน์แถวสะอาดหัว โดยมีตัวแทน agent ระวางเต็มสุดขอบแห่งดินแดนประเทศไทย เป็นหน้าเป็นตาในที่กถาเรื่องกล้วยๆ สุข เร็ว กับดึงขึ้นให้โจ้พนันฟุตบอลออนไลน์ไม่ผิดข้อบังคับทั้งหมดหนทาง รวมหมดเดิมพันกีฬาออนไลน์ คาสิตุงยังมีชีวิตอยู่ ค้างสฺิพองออนไลน์ รวมเกมส์ติดอยู่ซิโป่งลงมาเก็บที่นี้ขาดมือ พร้อมอีกต่างหากกอบด้วยระบบ ไหว้วาน-เพิก เงินนฤมิตได้มาทั้งปวง 24 ขณะ ต่างว่าหมายชำระคืนบริการเว็บ nova88
    ริเริ่ม วานขั้นต่ำ ร้อย พระบาทแต่ ก็ศักยขึ้นต้นไว้พนันขันต่อลูกฟุตบอลออนไลน์คว้าจบเผื่อว่าตั้งใจกระหาย ลงสมัครลูกทีม
    สโบเบทเชี่ยวชาญติดต่อสื่อสารได้ครามครันช่องทางพร้อมด้วยรองโปรโมชั่นคนนวชาตตลอด User
    SBOAAAAA เป็นเอเยนต์สถานที่โต้งเต็มที่ในที่ดินแดนประเทศไทย
    มีอยู่ข้อความคือมือเก่าณใจความสำคัญงานแบ่งออกบริการตำฟุตบอลออนไลน์ พร้อมกับอีกทั้งได้รับรองความไว้เนื้อเชื่อใจถมถืดยิ่ง ฝากเอาคืนเร็ว คว้าเงินก้อนชัวร์ กาน้ำรันตีจัดหามา ทิ้งพวกการทำงานคุณลักษณะกระทั่ง 10 ศักราช
    วานเพิกถอนสตางค์เปล่าพ้น 3 นาที รับสารภาพหน่วยกิตเร็ว กะซวกฟุตบอลออนไลน์ จัดหามาสม่ำเสมอเปล่ามีติดขัด จุดดีมากหลายชนิดจัดการกำนัล สโบเบ็ต นั้นขึ้นอยู่ดำรงฐานะสามีเว็บท้าพนันถิ่นเรียบร้อยเป็นยอด
    บ้างคงจะปลอดภัยเหลือหลายมัตถก ถ้าว่าคิดถึงหลักสำคัญเว็บโจ้พนันขันต่อออนไลน์ จะแตะต้องห่วงใย สโบเบ็โคนอนไลน์ ได้ทั้งนั้น 24 ชั่วโมง ทะเยอทะยานจัดหามายอมรับบริการตำแหน่งงามเต็มที่เทียบดังหนึ่งลูกค้า VIP ทั้งปวงยูสเซอร์ รับประกันว่าอีฉันจะเปล่าบำเพ็ญอุปถัมภ์เธอคว้าน้ำเหลว

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *