By James H. Smith, retired editor and president of the non-profit Connecticut Council on Freedom of Information
When Connecticut legislators met in secret last session, working with the families of the victims of the Sandy Hook Elementary School shootings, they came out from behind closed doors long enough to pass legislation making secret crime scene photos and certain 911 tapes of every homicide in the state henceforth.
The legislature also created a task force to study the balance between victim privacy and the public’s right to know, but stacked the 17-member body with privacy advocates. I am among the seven members clearly in favor of transparency.
When state Superior Court Judge Eliot Prescott, after listening to arguments last month from Danbury State’s Attorney Stephen Sedensky to keep the 911 tapes secret, ordered them released; Chief State’s Attorney Kevin Kane urged his fellow task force members to get moving and recommend laws that provide for more secrecy.
The task force has been meeting since August, and has adopted recommendations this month that would allow limited access to crime scene photographs, 911 recordings and other audio or video depicting the condition of homicide victims. The access recommended would be for citizens and journalists to listen to the audio tapes or view the photographs or visual images so long as copies are not made. It also creates a process for requesting copies which would shift the burden to the access seeker to show it is not an “unwarranted invasion of personal privacy” to release the copies.
This recommendation came after months of meetings where the viewpoints of open government advocates and victims’ advocates were in sharp relief. It is clear listening to the tapes of staffers at Sandy Hook School calling 911 while the shooting and killing was going on, that our society has things it must learn from those tapes. Law enforcement experts are now debating whether Newtown police responded correctly. Those tapes also show the courage of school staff and the calm and professionalism of police dispatchers.
Proponents of privacy sought to get rid of Connecticut’s “Perkins test” on releasing information about crimes, and “codify” the federal “Favish” standard, which essentially shifts the burden of proof from the government to the public on showing why investigative files should be made public. The problem with the Supreme Court Favish decision, keeping the photos of Clinton adviser Vince Foster secret, is that it requires a citizen to prove the photos are of legitimate public interest, but does not allow the citizen to see the photos.
The Connecticut Supreme Court Perkins decision has been the guide for releasing information for more than two decades. In order for information held by the government to remain hidden, the government must show that the information sought is “highly offensive to a reasonable person” AND is not of “legitimate public concern.” Both standards must be met, or the information is public.
Traditionally, Connecticut has been viewed as a state with envious FOI statutes, but the voices of privacy are touting federal “standards,” masking how the federal FOI laws are limpid compared to Connecticut’s.
The stated aim to “protect” Newtown families expanded to include the families of victims of all homicides when inner city legislators argued that the state is shielding white suburbanites and ignoring the plight of minorities. Presented with data that showed case after case of law enforcement malfeasance against minorities (the Connecticut chapter of the ACLU testified that 80 percent of police taserings in the state are against minorities) some task force members are rethinking the wisdom of closing files to the public. There is justice to be found in those files.
Co-chair of the task force Angel Arce, who represents Hartford in the state House of Representatives, issued a statement acknowledging that “constituents of urban districts… are more likely to be victimized by crime but they are also more susceptible to police abuse and mistreatment. We must have public oversight of law enforcement agencies and the criminally accused must have the capability to obtain information needed for their defense. I recognize that this is best accomplished through public disclosure of government records.”
But then he was also one of the members of the task force most vociferous in keeping that information from the public. Like all the privacy advocates, he says “I am confident that a balance can be struck in which we protect the dignity, privacy and safety of crime-victims and witnesses, but preserve the tools that are necessary to hold government accountable.” In the end, he supported the proposal exempting from copying crime scene images of homicide victims if the images “could reasonably be expected to constitute an unwarranted invasion of privacy.”
He espouses codifying the Favish standard, defining an invasion of privacy as “being ‘warranted’ if a requestor produces evidence sufficient to warrant a belief by a reasonable person that: 1. A government official acted negligently or otherwise improperly in the performance of his or her duties; and 2. The image requested is likely to be probative of such negligence or impropriety.”
The burden is shifted to public away from the government.
He supports the change to the law last year that puts off limits “that portion of an audio tape or other recording where the individual speaking . . . describes the condition of a victim of homicide.”
Chief States Attorney Kane, a task force member, supported permanently making that language the 28th exemption to the state FOI law. When the law passed in 1975 there were 10 exemptions.
The current compromise recommendation, brainchild of Klarn DePalma, general manager of WFSB-TV in Hartford and a task force member, would set up a depository for crime scene photos and allow copying only in cases where the requestor can show there is not an “unwarranted invasion of privacy.”
As president of the Connecticut Council on Freedom of Information, I am not seeking compromise. I hoped to see the restrictions the legislature passed last year repealed, and that the long-standing FOI laws on release of crime scene photos and 911 tapes, reinstated.
Now that the task force has prepared a report to the legislature, legislative leaders have promised the public hearings they did not have last session. Let us hope they keep their word.
Many transparency advocates have testified before the task force, a sampling:
“The passage of new legislation … modifying the Connecticut Freedom of Information Act severely damages the strength of what has been heretofore a model freedom of information regime. . . (and limits) understanding the truth.” Rosanna Cavanagh, NEFAC executive director
“Connecticut is heading down a dark path… becoming one of the more secretive in the nation… Connecticut (is now) ranked 25th in the nation… with these provisions it sinks into the more secretive part of the country. It’s now what I call a dark state … worse than New York and New Jersey.” David Cullier, PH.D., president of SPJ, director, School of Journalism, University of Arizona, Tuscon.
“There is no area where public transparency is more vital than in the administration of justice … when the police and prosecutorial powers of the state are exercised in the name of society at large… the public good requires a way to expose mistakes, inadequacies or misconduct in the criminal justice system.” Claude Albert of CCFOI
“The 29th Amendment to Connecticut’s Constitution addresses victim’s rights, but nowhere in that provision is there mention of ‘victim privacy.’ There is a very good reason for this omission. The amendment does require that victims be accorded ‘fairness and respect’ but nowhere in the constitution, either explicitly or implicitly, do victim rights override the fundamentals of all criminal law: 1. Criminal prosecutions are brought by the government on behalf of society as a whole; 2. The justice system is accountable to the people, as is the rest of government in a democracy. 3. Because of the extraordinary powers conferred by the people on the police, prosecutors and courts, fairness for the accused and transparency to society are the essential prerequisites to the credibility of the criminal justice system.” Mitchell W. Pearlman, retired executive director of the Connecticut FOIC
“Government, our forefathers taught us, is susceptible to all sorts of unscrupulous pressure. After the mass killings at Columbine High School in 1999, the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Department knowingly withheld vital information from the public — and more importantly — from the families of the victims themselves for five years. Why? To avoid the possibility of embarrassment and lawsuits. . . Keeping information from the public can actually have the effect of enflaming opinion. At Columbine and at Newtown, conspiracy theorists were at work almost immediately. Facts — clear-eyed information – are the best, and possibly the only, antidote to such unbridled speculation.” Jonathan Kellogg, executive editor of the Waterbury Republican and past president of NESNE.
Hi blogger, i must say you have very interesting posts here.
Your website should go viral. You need initial
traffic boost only. How to get it? Search for; Mertiso’s
tips go viral
viagra price comparison viagra without a doctor prescription how much is viagra
side effects of cialis cialis generic names for cialis and viagra
cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy viagra generic viagra names
over the counter ed remedies ed and diabetes erectile dysfunction
buying viagra online buy ed pills online best place to buy viagra online
viagra online canadian pharmacy buy viagra from canada best place to buy generic viagra online
viagra canada generic viagra online how to get viagra
ed treatment ED Pills is it illegal to buy prescription drugs online
ed pills online pharmacy Cheap Erection Pills pills erectile dysfunction
home remedies for erectile dysfunction generic cialis erectal disfunction
buy prescription drugs without doctor Cheap Erection Pills best cure for ed
cialis headaches afterwards cialis for sale cialis without doctor prescription
canadian viagra cialis cialis for sale cialis without doctor prescription
ed pills online pharmacy can ed be cured ed drugs online
the best ed pills
cheap online pharmacy cheap medication online medications for
canadian online drugs
ed doctors ed drugs over the counter ed natural treatment
best male enhancement
generic vs real careprost https://carepro1st.com/
https://ventolin100mcg.com/ can i buy ventolin online
https://doxycylinegeneric100.com/
https://zithromaxgeneric500.com/ zithromax for sale cheap
https://prednisonegeneric20.com/ prednisone 20mg by mail order
naltrexone and fibromyalgia pain https://naltrexoneonline.confrancisyalgomas.com/
buy sildenafil buy sildenafil online
tadalafil pharmacy tadalafil online
buy tadalafil online tadalafil canada
best place to buy generic drugs buy generic drugs online
tadalafil canada tadalafil pharmacy
hydroxychloroquine use in europe https://hhydroxychloroquine.com/
cheapest sildenafil cheap sildenafil
scabies treatment ivermectin dose https://ivermectin.mlsmalta.com/
payday loans no credit check instant approval payday loans
sildenafil without doctor prescription sildenafil online
Howdy! I know this is kinda off topic however , I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My website discusses a lot of the same subjects as yours and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to shoot me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Great blog by the way!|
hydroxychloroquine 200mg 60 tablets https://hydroxychloroquine.webbfenix.com/
generic ed drugs https://sildenafilxxl.com/ order viagra online
canadian pharmacy viagra buy viagra viagra pills
walgreens generic vidalista price https://vidalista40mg.mlsmalta.com/
non prescription viagra generic viagra viagra cost per pill
medication for ed dysfunction buy Zithromax herbal ed treatment
is it illegal to buy prescription drugs online generic drugs pills for erection
generic viagra india viagra sale generic viagra walmart
male enhancement products best online canadian pharmacy ed symptoms
show cialis working cialis the effects of cialis on women
non prescription viagra viagra coupons 75% off cheapest viagra online
cialis samples request cialis tadalafil how much does cialis cost at walmart
viagra prescription online generic viagra online viagra
cure for ed buy Nolvadex cvs prescription prices without insurance
interactions for cialis taking l-citrulline and cialis together cialis dosages
viagra otc viagra for sale viagra pill
cialis coupon code generic cialis cialis or viagra
viagra vs cialis vs levitra cialis cialis prices 20mg
viagra cost cheap viagra online pharmacy viagra
best pharmacy online cheap Doxycyline best male enhancement pills
cialis vs viagra cialis online cialis going generic in 2019 in us
cialis vs levitra generic cialis п»їcialis
top ed drugs Zithromax india erectyle disfunction
real cialis without a doctor prescription generic cialis cialis daily
pain meds online without doctor prescription Nolvadex what are ed drugs
taking cialis and sildenafil together https://wisig.org/
how to purchase priligy online https://ddapoxetine.com/
canadian drug prices: natural drugs for ed drug prices comparison
amstyles.com https://amstyles.com/
the best ed drug: ed therapy vacuum pump for ed
viagra without doctor prescription: ed pills cheap drugs online
buy generic zithromax no prescription buy generic zithromax no prescription zithromax cost canada
zithromax z-pak cost of generic zithromax generic zithromax azithromycin
plaquenil for covid 19 prophylaxis https://hydroxychloroquinee.com/
п»їcialis warnings for cialis cialis tadalafil 20 mg
how much is viagra viagra discount generic name for viagra
real cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy viagra online canada pharmacy dog antibiotics without vet prescription
erectile dysfunction medications canadian online pharmacies erection problems
canada cialis canadien cialis cost of cialis 20mg tablets
coupons for cialis cialis pills generic cialis no doctor’s prescription
how long does 20mg cialis keep in system cialis free trial buy viagra cialis
viagra cialis order viagra generic online viagra
buy generic 100mg viagra online
roman viagra viagra for sale buy generic 100mg viagra online
viagra professional
viagra cialis order viagra generic generic viagra cost
canadian online pharmacy viagra
buy generic viagra online order viagra generic online viagra prescription
online pharmacy viagra
cialis generic tadalafil walmart https://tadalafili.com/
viagra coupons viagra without doctor prescription viagra online canadian pharmacy
how to get viagra
cheap viagra viagra for sale cheap viagra
best place to buy viagra online
is doxycycline a strong antibiotic http://doxycycline.zolftgenwell.org/
buy erection pills ed meds top erectile dysfunction pills
cenmox 250 cheap antibiotics buy prescription drugs online
Doxycycline antibiotics cheap Flagyl canadian medications
best non prescription ed pills cheap antiviral drugs buy Valtrex online
buy Amoxil online cheap antibiotics male erection
canadian drug pharmacy top erection pills ed meds online
buy medications online best rated canadian pharmacies online pharmacies without an rx
Flagyl antibiotics buy Doxycycline online prescription drugs online without doctor
comfortis for dogs without vet prescription Valtrex Aciclovir
Flagyl buy Cenmox ed clinics
best ed treatment canadian pharmacy certified canadian online pharmacies
buy ed pills online ed meds rx top erectile dysfunction pills
best male ed pills canadian pharmacies shipping usa reputable mail order pharmacies canada
medications online best ed solution generic ed pills
erectile dysfunction medication approved canadian online pharmacies canada drugs online
real viagra without a doctor prescription canada online pharmacy canada drugs
solutions for ed lipitor generic india atorvastatin lipitor
cialis manufacturer coupon card https://www.lm360.us/
cialis coupon cheap cialis take cialis with or without food
canadian drug pharmacy canada drug pharmacy online pharmacy canada
is there a generic for viagra buy viagra online cheapest generic viagra
natural ed treatments website buy ed pills online
buy ed pills online approved canadian online pharmacies canada online pharmacy
viagra without a doctor prescription usa roman viagra viagra price comparison
drugs for ed canada drug pharmacy canada online pharmacy
cialis pills buy cialis cialis prices
qaubyyzr viagra without a doctor prescription canada goodrx viagra
jlpkthtz cheap viagra viagra over the counter walmart
non prescription viagra https://cheapvgr100.com/ fjhrelnw
amazon viagra https://cheapvgr100.online/ hvkicbid
where can i buy benadryl generic benadryl tablets allegra 200
strongest antibiotic for bacterial infection doxycycline order online zithromax 500 mg for sale
At this moment I am going to do my breakfast, afterward having my breakfast coming yet again to read additional news.|
macrodantin antibiotic doxycycline 100mg capsules homemade antibiotic
valacyclovir valtrex valtrex generic no prescription buy real valtrex online
zyrtec for sinus infection order benadryl online zyrtec nasal spray
sxt antibiotic amoxicillin 500mg buy online uk amoxicillin without a doctors prescription
buy doxycycline online zithromax order online uk buy generic bactrim
nolvadex 20 mg https://tamoxifen.mrdgeography.com/
alesse acne serophene buy serophene otc
drinking with vidalista https://vidalista.mlsmalta.com/
get valtrex online buy valtrex australia valtrex cost canada
My relatives every time say that I am killing my time here at web, but I know I am getting experience every day by reading such fastidious content.|
levlen pill nz yasmin pill generic pilex tablets online
zithromax 500 without prescription cat antibiotic bactrim forte
buy doxycycline online 270 tabs how to buy amoxicillin online bactrim pill
how to get valtrex prescription famvir cost india acyclovir herpes
I was wondering if you ever considered changing the page layout of your site? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having one or 2 pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?|
allegra 15 allegra 120 price in india zyrtec usa price
Hi to all, the contents existing at this site are actually remarkable for people knowledge, well, keep up the good work fellows.|
benefits of amoxicillin for women https://amoxycillin1st.com/
canadian pharmacy viagra http://viagrastm.online/ canadian viagra xshpuwaq
cdlkizqw how long does 20mg cialis keep in system http://cialisirt.com/ buy cialis online
cialis dosage http://cialisirt.com/ canada price on cialis wqhzzdam
oqntutkt generic viagra without a doctor prescription http://viagrastm.online/ how much viagra should i take the first time?
cheap viagra online canadian pharmacy http://viagrastm.com/ canadian viagra yjryyarf
mscfucqr switching from tamsulosin to cialis http://cialisirt.online/ when is the best time to take cialis
viagra generic http://viagrastm.com/ is there a generic viagra dkctoxzj
bbuvhbch cost of cialis http://cialisirt.com/ does viagra or cialis help with pe
over the counter viagra http://viagrastm.com/ viagra discount klzsdbjv
herbal remedies for ed canadian express pharmacy male dysfunction pills
erectile dysfunction medicines https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com causes for ed
mens ed pills https://canadianpharmacyvikky.com what type of medicine is prescribed for allergies
ed treatment review canadian mail-order pharmacy natural remedies for ed problems
Pingback: portable atmospheric water generator
ed pills that really work
https://canadarx24.com/
canadian drug prices
levitra without a doctor prescription https://canadarx24.com/
ed and diabetes
male ed drugs
https://canadarx24.com/
online ed meds
over the counter ed remedies https://canadarx24.com/
male dysfunction treatment
dysfunction erectile pnzovdbh levitra pet meds without vet prescription canada
buy viagra cialis take cialis with or without food eanhljdb real cialis without a doctor prescription
generic viagra online for sale bxyvobke sildenafil generic for viagra
how much will generic viagra cost egrlhmmj buy sildenafil is there a generic for viagra
Pingback: superbeets
viagra or cialis cialis nwyreqml how much does cialis cost at walmart
natural ed zfgnvwye levitra online male dysfunction
how much viagra should i take the first time? oqjtegvx generic viagra mexican viagra
kyzd viagra from india http://dietkannur.org htmy kpae
edul buy viagra http://dietkannur.org xrrz pjdu
buy prescription viagra medications without a doctor’s prescription
medications without a doctor’s prescription buy prescription viagra online without
tindr , what is tinder https://tinderdatingsiteus.com/